Mafia - Lynch the Snitch a game brought to you by Sharpe12 Productions.

you missed my vote for some reason

Unvote

Vote Jasper

As of right now the only person I find it hard for kaleg to partner with is Baka, that being said, FAs D2 request for additional information on kalegs role makes me think she done goof'd and demanded answers (in a nice way) for that reason alone I'm going to lean a bit heavy on the FA over Jasper side right now.

vote FA

There's only one immediate RC that would really change my mind and the role shouldn't be in the game (I'd think) so I have to go with my guy on it.

LOL

Four people voting but each is on a different player. That's a bit odd on D3.

My read list looks like this:

LM: Top suspect. His push on Turkeh on D2 coupled with his push pm me today both feel like pushing some real weak sauce.

Jasper: While Jasper seemed to have sheeped LM twice I had a feeling he and Kaleg were not scum together based on their communication with each other on D1. I could be wrong, yes, but I usually trust my D1 impressions over those of later days.

FA: Something tells me she's Town. I don't know how to put it in words, but her posting style and analysis look too straight forward to come from Scum!FA

bam: He's Town I'm sure. It would not have been hard for Scum!bam to find a reason to vote Turkeh on D2, and it would have been in his best interest to do so. Instead he defended her and made it clear he won't be voting her long before the day ended.

We need to use the extension well if we intend to solve this puzzle.

I did not play the game the way I should and the way I would cause of time issues but I'm not scum. I asked about kaleg's role cause this is beginners and in this game all ability/roles must get outed when someone dies as there can't be a janitor.

But if you're trying to find excuses to vote me, be my guest

I'll try to explain to you guys my line of thoughts after i did a fast reread.

I don't really see Jasper being scum here, since day one he's been advocating for a lynch and I find nothing wrong with that. Sure his methods might be somewhat unorthodox (like the "let's just lynch FA" part), I could be wrong about him but he's struck me as a sincere yet lazy townie from the beginning.
One thing I have to say to you, while I was on board with you on the idea of needing a lynch so badly. Today I have to be careful, because any miss lynch would most likely put us at LyLo the next day phase. Not saying a lynch would be a bad idea, just the wrong one would be.

Bamcbix, you didn't really give much to work with the first couple of days, but you have been contributing more actively since day three including voting me (even tho I don't agree with your reasons.)
At first I was more suspicious a bit of you when you defended Turkeh during day two (regardless of her flip after she was NK, I didn't know what she would flip) then she flipped as town and I grew more suspicious thinking that you knew how she'd flip town and you defended her for town cred. Reading back, I realized you didn't defend Turkeh cause you thought she was town, was more because you thought I didn't have a solid case against her.
I'm still unsure about your alignment, you're a difficult read for me cause I always peg you as scum.
My question to you is why do you think FA would shoot Kaleg of all people?

Now off to FA, after your back and forth with Kaleg during day one then Kaleg flipping as scum the next day, I had you pretty much in the town camp, thinking there's no way you'd be his partner. But I have to look beyond that and consider the possibility that you didn't know Kaleg was your partner and thus shot him at night.
So I have two questions for you, why did you think my posts at the start of day 2 to be authentic? And how come you said Baka was acting town in post #93 then said he's acting like scum baka early on on day 3 and finally call him town baka in your last post? it sounds very inconsistent.

Baka, I don't want to keep repeating myself here so I'll be quick with this. I have every right to doubt you, there is nothing scummy with that. You spent two days practically doing nothing and the only thin you offered to the table was the theory about the scum buddies not knowing each other, so yes I find it scummy and will not think twice about speaking up.
But I have a question for you as well Baka, since you've already pegged everyone else as town but me, what if I told you I was town? you have no reason to believe me, I know. But lets say I get lynched today and tomorrow would be a brand new day phase and the game is not over? who would be your suspect then?

I need sometime to think before I vote and hopefully I'll get all of your answers before I do.

I didn't read the rest of that long post cause I just woke up and I need to get ready to go to work.

- I said genuine not authentic. I found your desire to figure out what kaleg was genuine spescially the evaluation about colors since there was no colors in the role pm I received and i'm assuming everyone else were like that. This logic has no place if the scums didn't know each other though and it actually can be interpreted as you were surprised to see your partner dead.
- I found baka's NK anlysis pretty scummy but in that post he reached out to me saying he wouldn't kill me in a way that I'm sure a scum would never do if my role is the reason scum n1 kill failed.

@Monster: The read list is ordered from scummiest to towniest. This means I have Jasper in my sight still, but the D1 thing makes me doubt he's Kaleg's p.

This makes no sense here and has done nothing but confuse me. Can you explain it to me FA? Cause basically you're saying you have an explanation about the no kill on N1, but there was a kill N1. Kaleg's death, which you say you're not sure how it happened?

@baka. It's still possible for the mafia not to lynch Turkeh and then shoot her during the night. Remember her last post when the day ended? She dropped something. She said she know more than she should which I take as a PR hint. The mafia could have seen that also so the mafia decided to kill her.

I have a possible explanation that there was no kill on Town. I don't know about the kill on Kaleg

@Jasper: Not really. What she said was she asked the mod about her role (and frankly I would have too if I was told I was a chef!). Your point is taken though.

@LM your question to me is kinda illogical. Why? Well the better question is why not? We have to assume that they didn't know the existence of each other (it's also a fair assumption due to the whole snitch concept) so what reason would anyone have to not kill anyone random?

@Sharpe12: Could you please list the roles of the flipped players next to their names?

I will try to analyze the kills to see if they point to someone in particular. It may seem that FA was the hardest to lynch (only bam would vote her I think), but I'm not sure that's the only reason she got killed.

Could it be her speculation about the N1 kill (or the lack of one)?? Maybe she was thought to be a PR? That's a very valid proposition. But that also means the killer is shooting the suspected PRs, so why on the planet did they shoot Kaleg on N1?

Whoever it is, I'd like you to explain how you decided on your kills post game.

At least my read wasn't wrong about FA, but I'm starting to reconsider my other reads.

For starters, Baka. You were my primary suspect on day three, mainly cause of your lack of input on day one and two. I felt like you were posting just about enough to get you through without actually trying to scumhunt and the fact that I was your only suspect on day three (the only person I knew for sure to be town) didn't help your case either.
But due to lack of reads, I'm gonna have to trust FA's final read on you and put you on the town side.

Bam, I like the way Bam's been acting since day three and he didn't have to unvote me at the beginning. Pretty sure I would've been hammered and lynched otherwise.

So this leaves me with Jasper, I now do believe he is the last scum mostly because I don't think the other two are. Also, I've been trying to ignore this since day three's opening story and dismissing it as just a flavor thing but it has become a bit repetitive.
This was after Turkeh had voted Jasper.


this is again after FA voted him as well.

Vote Jasper